Summary
Quick Links
In 2024, it was announced thatCase Closedauthor Gōshō Aoyama’sYAIBAmanga would be adapted into an anime for the first time since the original anime adaptation, which ran over 30 years ago in 1993. The 2025 adaptation, titledYAIBA: Samurai Legend, has had a brilliant resurgence courtesy of WIT Studio, the production studio best known for their work on the first three seasons of2025 Crunchyroll Global Impact Award winner,Attack on Titan.
It goes without saying that the 2025 version has had a significant visual upgrade from the nostalgic style of anime in the 1990s, but how do the two adaptations of YAIBA compare to each other?
What is YAIBA About?
Samurai? In theHeiseiReiwa Era?
YAIBAfollows the titular character, Yaiba Kurogane, a young boy raised away from the hustle and bustle of modern life by his father deep in the woods on an island somewhere off the south coast of the Japanese archipelago. The only thing he knows is the way of the sword, and he aspires to become a samurai, not realizing that samurai are now relics of a bygone era. At some point, Yaiba’s father tells him that he has nothing left to teach him, and sends him off to Japan to stay with Raizo Mine, a kendo master who sees Yaiba’s father as the only thing standing in between him andgenuine mastery of the blade.
Yaiba must continue his training under the tutelage of the Mines, including Raizo’s teenage daughter, Sayaka, whose life is upturned by the presence of the boorish sword-crazy kid now living in her house. Sayaka’s school boasts a continental-level kendo team, of which Takeshi Onimaru is the most skilled by far. Excited by the premise of facing a powerful opponent, Yaiba challenges Onimaru and is swiftly outclassed, kick-starting a rivalry that neither of them realize will become central to the return of powerful supernatural entities who have been at odds for hundreds of years.
Brave Sword Legend Yaiba (1993)andYAIBA: Samurai Legend (2025)are both based on theYAIBAmanga by Gōshō Aoyama. It was serialized in Shogakukan’s shōnen manga magazine Weekly Shōnen Sunday from September 1988 to December 1993, and it was collected into 24 volumes. The manga has been licensed for release in English by VIZ Media. TheYAIBAmanga won the 38th Shogakukan Manga Award in the shōnen category in 1993, and by May 2024, the manga had over 17 million copies in circulation.
The originalYAIBAanime was produced by Studio Pastel, and ran for 52 episodes, while it isn’t clear how many episodes the WIT Studio-produced 2025 reboot has been slated for. The reboot is directed by Takahiro Hasui (storyboards,Bungō Stray Dogs), with Tōko Machida (script,Akame ga KILL!) writing the series script, Yoshimichi Kameda (alien & yōkai designs,DANDADAN) serving as chief director and character designer, and Yutaka Yamada and Yoshiaki Dewa composing the music.
Let’s Talk About Atmosphere
Reviving a Relic of a Bygone Era
The main difference anyone who watches both iterations of theYAIBAanime will notice is the fact that the 1993 version is most definitely a product of its time, with the kind of goofy humour that definitely invokes nostalgia in any anime fans who were watching anime in the 1990s, early 2000s, or even before that. There is an unmistakable feel of a bygone era in the original anime, which is to be expected, and the pacing is probably the biggest element that reflects this “old skool” atmosphere.
For those who grew up watching anime, the 1993YAIBAinvokes a familiarity that really hits home, especially if one of the titles you interacted with in your youth was the originalDragon Ball. Yaiba Kurogane as a character is most definitelyan expy of Son Gokuin his childhood, and that clear connection might not necessarily have been what Aoyama was going for when he created him, but as an anime coming out in a post-Dragon Balllandscape during the golden era of the medium; a time almost characterized by anime with this kind of atmosphere and pacing,YAIBAis emblematic of that time.
This understanding of the originalYAIBAmakes watching WIT Studio’s reboot even sweeter, as it somehow manages to capture some of that atmosphere while having clear and intentioned improvements to not just the art and animation, but also direction and the series' inherent sense of humour. The 1993YAIBAanime was humourous in the kind of slapstick way one would expect from Shōnen of that time, sometimes even feeling like it took notes from the various works ofmanga legend Rumiko Takahashi(Inuyasha, Maison Ikkoku, Urusei Yatsura, Ranma 1/2), which is likely because it reflects the sensibilities of Heisei Era comedy. The goofy vibe of the 1993YAIBApermeates every aspect of the early series, while the 2025 version manages to weave together some humorous highs together with a flair for the dramatic that makes the goofiness of the series feel less pervasive, but still very evident.
Story Beats and Pacing
Less Gags, More Character Writing Make For a Brilliant Reboot
Given the fact that the originalYAIBAcame out over 30 years ago, it goes without saying that the story tries to achieve something different from the 2025 iteration. As mentioned previously, the original anime is far goofier than its reboot, which is aligned to different values and sensibilities when it comes to entertainment. The original is definitely a product of its time, which is why the reboot, despite some of its major stylistic and directional changes, still feels like a faithful reboot and/or adaptation, as it, too, is a product of its time.
These days, action anime is all aboutimpactful scenes with dazzling sakuga, variation in camera angles, fight choreography, and emphasis on character writing. In the 1993 version ofYAIBA, Onimaru is presented solely as a kendo-crazed athlete, while the 2025 version contextualizes his achievements in kendo, giving more depth to his character as it is also more deliberately contrasted with that ofYAIBAafter their first encounter. Onimaru is spurred on by his desire to make his sister, who is studying kendo overseas.
While Yaiba has a lively home life, especially after moving into the Mine house, Onimaru is very noticably by himself. The 2025 version of the anime also presents a softer side to Onimaru, which gives him a greater role than simply being the vessel of the antagonist, like when we see his gentleness when feeding pigeons, which parallels Yaiba’s own relationship with his pet tiger and vulture, Kagetora and Shonosuke. Speaking of Shonosuke, the bird is literally shipped to Tokyo alongside Kagetora and Yaiba in the 1993 version, while in the 2025 version, the relationship between Yaiba and his pets is illustrated by the vulture flying hundreds of kilometers just to find Yaiba.
There’sa greater sense of parallel between Yaiba and Onimaruthat makes their rivalry a lot more colourful than in the 1993 anime, and that makes for a more solid story overall. The supernatural feats also seem to come much earlier for both characters in the reboot, with their schoolyard mischief in the second episode being far more over-the-top than it was in the 1993 version, although their fight in the city was fairly similar to the original, albeit with far more engaging choreography. There is an evident desire to enhance the action and story as a whole while retaining that sense of whimsy that the original anime had, and that might be a big contributing factor to the success of theYAIBAreboot.
